Skip to main content

Will the Reverend Malthus have the last laugh? Karl Marx the second to the last?

In the undergrad course I teach "Environment and Society" one of the important environmental issues we take in class is human population growth. And no one can take stock of the issue without bumping into Thomas Robert Malthus and his theory on population.

Malthus was an Anglican country parson who wrote one of the most influential works in science "An Essay on the Principle of Population". This essay influenced Darwin and Wallace at a time they were formulating their evolutionary theory.

Malthus being a parish priest was able to create his theory from christening, marriage and funeral records. What better place to be a demographer!

Malthus' essay has three important concepts. Some environmental science textbooks call these as "prophecies" while some call it "predictions". For the sake of scientific objectivity, I prefer the latter term.

The predictions are

1) Population will increase exponentially as long as their is enough food (Malthus initially modelled growth in a geometric progression)
2) Humans like to have sex
3) Eventually populations will exceed the capacity of the earth to produce food and population will crash. (Malthus suggested that food production follows an arithmetic progression)

The first has been observed in the lab and our good ol'e ecology textbooks have the classic examples. The second needs no science to prove! The third remains a hypothesis but in lab cultures this can be observed.

Advances in agriculture and medicine have proven the third prediction as unfounded until quite recently (yesterday!). Now the blurbs have screaming headlines of "food crisis" at a global scale and some scientists have suggested we revisit Malthus' ideas.

Malthus may have the last laugh. Our paradigm of technology being able to forestall the third prediction is based on an assumption of the unlimited resources our planet can provide. But Malthus presciently recognized that this isn't true.

Mathusian theory has its critics. Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels were the most notable of them all. Marx argued that what Malthus saw as the poor's tendency to reproduce beyond their means is a dynamic of the capitalist system.

Marx and Engels may have the second-to-the last laugh since Malthus has been proven wrong on one account. Human population growth rates have slowed down in the last 50 years and this should have made food security more certain. But it isn't. Instead we see an increase in the use of natural resources. The only explanation for the phenomenon is the global capitalist system. In no time of human history has more than 2 billion people (India and China) becoming capitalist. This is definitelty placing a strain on the planet's carrying capacity.

Malthus and Marx have seen the two sides of the same coin. A new paradigm has to be set in coming to grips with world food insecurity which is a sign of the global environmental catastrophe Jared Diamond has written and warned us about.


sparks said…
There are Chinese academics who make the proposition that China has embraced the logic of capitalism to defeat it. I.e., as it continues to grow and consume, it will push the Earth's resources beyond its limit. This is quite scary. Now that it has run the US market until it is spent (consumption based on credit), economists are urging China to develop the consuming power of its domestic market. 1.3 billion people. Indians, another 1 billion people. Yeah, Marx may have the last laugh indeed.
blackshama said…
Sparks. You are right. We recall that Malthusian Theory is antithetical to the Marxist one. But it looks like that both Karl and Thomas are probably laughing in their demographic heaven or is it hell?
DJB Rizalist said…
interesting column by David Ignatius in WashPo. He claims the Fed is essentially fueling the next big crisis: Global Inflation.
DJB Rizalist said…
regarding, marx, engels and malthus, it seems to me that the power of new technology, both scientific and social, has always helped us get past the civilization ending scenarios they've all painted.

But it makes me wonder given the scale of what is happening now. The rise of India and China certainly makes one wonder if there could be too much progress in one sphere (economic) before we develop the knowledge or wisdom about how to deal with it.
blackshama said…

The irony is that China and India have the philosophical tradition of harmony with nature!

The capitalism of the West has really screwed things up!
Danielle Uidam said…
Over population is a huge issue. I just finished writing a novel, The Malthus Conspiracy, and although fictional, it highlights some of the issues that Malthus outlined, and some of the issues today. I hope more attention is drawn to the issues overpopulation brings!

Popular posts from this blog

Simoun's lamp has been lit, finally.. not by one but by the many!

"So often have we been haunted by the spectre of subversion which, with some fostering, has come to be a positive and real being, whose very name steals our serenity and makes us commit the greatest blunders... If before the reality, instead of changing the fear of one is increased, and the confusion of the other is exacerbated, then they must be left in the hands of time..."
Dr Jose Rizal "To the Filipino People and their Government"
Jose Rizal dominates the Luneta, which is sacred to the Philippine nation as a place of martyrdom. And many perhaps all of those executed in the Luneta, with the exception of the three Filipino secular priests martyred in 1872, have read Rizal's El Filibusterismo. Dr Rizal's second novel is a darker and more sinister one that its prequel but has much significance across the century and more after it was published for it preaches the need for revolution with caveats,  which are when the time is right and who will instigate it.

President Manuel Luis Quezon's Code of Ethics

Being a denizen of Kyusi, in honour of the man who gave my city its name and for being the most colourful prez the Philippines ever had, I have the pleasure to post Manuel L Quezon's Code of Ethics on his birthday. Let us profit from the wisdom of the Kastila.

1. Have Faith in the Divine Providence that guides the destinies of men and nations.

2. Love your country for it is the home of your people, the seat of your affection and the source of your happiness and well-being. It's defense is your primary duty. Be ready to sacrifice and die for it if necessary.

3. Respect the Constitution which is the expression of your sovereign will. The government is your government. It has been established for your safety and welfare. Obey the laws and see that they are observed by all and that public officials comply with their duties.

4. Pay your taxes willingly and promptly. Citizenship implies not only rights but obligations.

5. Safeguard the purity of suffrage and abide by the decisions of the…

Flame trees in bloom

The hottest summer courtesy of El Nino in at least 10 years gave runners and walkers in the University of the Philippines Diliman campus a visual treat. This year the flame trees Delonix regia are in full bloom!
In past summers it wasn't as hot and dry so the trees did not shed their leaves and few blooms were produced.
It is the tropical version of the Japanese Hanami or the Cherry blossom viewing season. While Hanami tells us the fragile impermanence of beauty, the flame tree hanami tells us that summer burns but soon it will all be over.